Ok, this happened! I finished reading Vygotsky in the original.
Lev Vygotsky’s book “Thought and Language” is the fundamental book by my favourite early childhood education theorist. I have been reading it for the past few months, making notes, thinking and trying to apply the key takeaways to my practice. Some of these ideas I am sharing here with you!
The book is hard to read. It investigates the connection between thinking and language, their development, and mutual influence. It is written in academic language, but Vygotsky is a good writer and overall it was a pleasure to read.
Vygotsky asserts that thought and speech have different origins but merge during a child’s development, forming a complex unity. Speech becomes a means of thinking, and thinking becomes a means of structuring speech
- In the early stages of child development, thinking and speech exist independently.
- Gradually, they merge, leading to the emergence of inner speech – or private speech, serving as an instrument of thought.
The concept of word meaning is central, which Vygotsky describes as the unity of thought and language. Word meaning changes and becomes more complex as the child develops, reflecting thought processes.
Vygotsky believes that the development of thinking and speech occurs in a social context through interaction with others. He calls it collaboration or “sotrudnichestvo” (this is me flexing my Russian – haha). Speech initially has an external, communicative function, then becomes internal.
The theorist introduces the concept of the Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) to show how social interaction promotes learning and cognitive development, expanding the child’s capabilities beyond their current level.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmBGzQcrn7A&t=12s
I was not surprised that most of the book is critique of Piaget theories. Vygotsky criticises Jean Piaget for underestimating the social nature of speech and thought, especially in the context of their interrelationship.
“Thought and Language” is a fundamental work in which Vygotsky describes speech activity as a key mechanism for the development of thinking and emphasises the influence of cultural and social environment on cognitive development.
Modern neuroscience broadly supports many of Lev Vygotsky’s key ideas, particularly those related to the development of the brain, thinking, and language. However, the approaches differ: Vygotsky focused on social and cultural dynamics, while neuroscience examines these processes at the level of biological mechanisms. Here are the main points that neuroscience confirms or clarifies:
The Connection Between Language and Thought
Modern research shows that language plays a central role in shaping and structuring thought. For instance, activation of the frontal lobes (e.g., Broca’s area) during language use supports the idea that speech and thought are interdependent.
Language influences cognitive processes such as memory, perception, and planning. For example, bilingualism enhances executive control functions, aligning with Vygotsky’s view that language is integral to the development of complex cognitive skills. In other words, children who speak more than one language, may have faster code-switching abilities , compared to their monolingual peers.
Development of Speech in Children
Neuroscience confirms that young children initially use language for communication (external speech) and later develop inner speech. This is reflected in changes in neural connections in the prefrontal cortex and limbic system as children mature.
The Social Nature of Development
It is a cornerstone of his theory – that development and learning happen in a social context. Vygotsky argued that learning and cognitive development occur through interaction with others. Neuroscience supports this, showing that a child’s brain is highly sensitive to social stimuli. Activity in brain areas related to empathy and social perception (e.g., mirror neurons) highlights the importance of interaction for learning.
The Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD)
While ZPD is a concept from pedagogy, its neurobiological parallels can be found in theories of neuroplasticity. The brain adapts and develops through learning when tasks are in the optimal range of difficulty and the child receives support from more knowledgeable mentors. In practical terms, ZPD can be used for the analysis of observations daily; you can adjust the level of support, based on the child’s current level of understanding of the concept or the ability to perform the task.
The Role of Speech in Self-Regulation
Vygotsky proposed that inner speech (or private speech) helps children regulate their behaviour and thinking. Think of the child who is talking to you as they get dressed or pack up their lunchbox, drawing something and explaining it to you. Research shows that language is indeed linked to self-regulation and executive functions, such as inhibiting impulsive reactions and managing attention. Very important process, which Vygotsky’s research unveiled.
Are there any limitations?
Yes! Vygotsky placed more emphasis on social and cultural factors than biological ones. Neuroscience brings balance by demonstrating that genetics and biology are equally important. Hence, exercise, diet, safe environment are as important as learning with others and scaffolding. Neuroscience clarifies that while thought and speech are interconnected, they can function independently, as seen in certain cognitive disorders.
Want to learn more about Vygotsky and other theories?
Download my guide to theories here👇🏼
Storykate 🪇
